top of page

The First 24 Hours: Why Crisis Communication Can Make or Break a Reputation

Writer: Rachel Balash
Rachel Balash
Nov 7
5 min read

When everything is moving quickly, knowing when—and how—to respond can make all the difference.



A crisis doesn't usually come with a warning.


Sometimes it's an unhappy customer. Sometimes it's an allegation, a social media post, or a situation that suddenly attracts attention you never expected.


One minute, you're running your business. The next, you're trying to figure out how something got so far out of control.


And while you're trying to understand what happened, everyone else seems to have already formed an opinion.


That's the difficult thing about a reputational crisis. You don't always get the opportunity to explain yourself before people decide what they believe.


The first 24 hours can have a lasting impact on your reputation. But what you do during that time matters far more than how quickly you can put out a statement.


Not Every Situation Requires an Immediate Response


One of the biggest mistakes a business can make during a crisis is responding simply because it feels pressured to do so.


I understand the instinct.


When people are talking about you or your business, the natural reaction is to defend yourself. You want to correct the record, explain what happened, and make the conversation stop.

But an immediate response isn't always the right response.


If you haven't established the facts, you risk making statements you'll later have to correct. If you're responding emotionally, you may say something that becomes an entirely separate controversy.


And if you engage in every argument online, you can unintentionally give a situation more attention than it would have received otherwise.


Being strategic doesn't mean being passive. It means understanding what you're responding to before deciding how to respond.


Silence Can Be Strategic. Avoidance Cannot.


There's a difference between choosing not to speak and having absolutely no idea what to say.


Sometimes the most responsible decision is to wait until you have accurate information. This is especially important when a situation involves legal concerns, employee matters, or allegations that haven't been verified.


But waiting should never mean ignoring the situation.


Behind the scenes, someone should be gathering facts, assessing potential consequences, identifying who needs information, and preparing for what may happen next.


If customers or employees are directly affected, they may need communication even when a public statement isn't appropriate.


The point isn't to say something just to say something.


It's to make sure that when you do speak, your words have purpose.


You Cannot Control Every Conversation About Your Business


This is something every business owner needs to understand.


You can work for years building relationships, earning trust, and establishing your reputation.


Then one incident, one accusation, or one widely shared post can change the conversation almost overnight.


That doesn't necessarily mean the public has all the facts.


It means people are reacting to the information available to them.


And in today's environment, information spreads much faster than context.


Trying to control every opinion is an impossible task. What you can control is how you conduct yourself, how you communicate, and whether your response gives people a reason to trust you.


That's where strategy becomes essential.


What I Believe Every Business Should Do in the First 24 Hours


Before anyone starts drafting statements or responding to comments, there are several questions that need answers.


What actually happened?


Not what someone posted. Not what people are assuming. What can you verify?


Who is affected?


Your customers? Employees? Business partners? The broader public? The people directly affected may deserve attention before everyone else.


How serious is the situation?


A negative review is not the same as a safety issue, a legal allegation, or a widespread public controversy. Treating every situation like a catastrophe can create unnecessary damage.


Who should be communicating?


When several people start speaking on behalf of a business without coordinating, the message becomes inconsistent. That creates confusion and can weaken credibility.


What happens after the first response?


A crisis doesn't necessarily end when you publish a statement. You need to know how you'll handle questions, new information, and developments that may change the situation.


These aren't complicated questions.


But they're much harder to answer when emotions are running high and everyone expects an immediate solution.


That's why having a plan before something happens is so important.


Defending Yourself Isn't Always the Same as Protecting Your Reputation


This is a distinction I think gets overlooked.


When your business is criticized, you may feel compelled to prove that you're right.


But reputation management isn't about winning an argument on Facebook.


It's about protecting credibility.


Sometimes that means acknowledging a mistake and explaining how you'll address it.


Sometimes it means correcting false information with facts.


And sometimes it means recognizing that engaging with someone publicly will accomplish absolutely nothing.


You have to consider the bigger picture.


What will your customers take away from this? How will employees interpret your response? What impression are you leaving with people who may be hearing about your business for the first time?


The loudest person in the conversation isn't necessarily the person whose opinion matters most to your business.


Preparation Is a Business Decision


Most business owners don't spend much time thinking about crisis communication until they need it.

They're focused on running their businesses, serving customers, managing employees, and keeping everything moving.


That's understandable.


But just as you prepare for financial challenges, operational disruptions, or unexpected expenses, you should have a plan for situations that threaten your reputation.


Who makes the final decision about public statements? Who handles media inquiries? When should an attorney be involved? How will employees receive information?


You don't need a hundred-page crisis manual to start preparing.


You need a clear understanding of your vulnerabilities, your responsibilities, and the decisions that cannot afford to be made impulsively.


Because when a situation escalates, the last thing you want is to be making every decision for the first time.


What People Remember


A crisis can expose a problem. It can also reveal something about an organization's leadership.


People notice whether you communicate clearly. They notice whether you're willing to take responsibility when appropriate. They notice when your words and actions don't align.


And they notice how you treat people when circumstances become difficult.


No communication strategy can guarantee that everyone will agree with you. That's not the objective.


The objective is to respond in a way that is thoughtful, credible, and appropriate to the situation.


The first 24 hours won't always determine the final outcome of a crisis. But they can establish the tone for everything that follows.


You may not get to choose when your reputation is questioned. You do get to choose how you respond.


And that choice deserves more than a reaction.


It deserves a strategy.


The Perspective | A Sovrana Strategic Journal

Sovrana Strategic

The Power of Perception.


Comments


bottom of page